Introduction to C2 Proficiency Writing Task 1 with TED talks: a case study

 
Sometimes introduction to exam preparation can (and arguably should) be integrated seamlessly into General English classes. In this post, I want to share an essay written by my wonderful student Olga who is in my wonderful General English C1+ group. The essay is based on two TED talks, so it turned out to be a great introduction to C2 Proficiency Writing Task 1. 

Preparation

  • It's not uncommon for me to use TED talks in class. But rather than work with one, I chose two talks this time:  

The talks discuss the same topic - a great career - but from different perspectives.  
  • I gave one talk to one to half of the group and the second one to the second half. 
  • I asked the students to prepare a summary of their talk for their partner and a vocabulary list that would help them present the summary. 
  • In class, what students did was they summarized their talk to their partner, using the vocabulary they had prepared, and then discussed each from the point of view whether they agreed with speakers. 
  • After class, I asked the students to put their vocabulary on our collaborative doc and watch their partner's talk.
And then it hit me, "Well, we've basically done C2 Proficiency Writing Task 1 now, but in speaking. It would be a crime not to ask the students to write it all up." So I did. I asked them to summarize and evaluate the talks, adding their opinions. The result is an essay driven by ideas and vocabulary. The skill will come in handy later, when the students embark on a preparation journey for real.  

Essay

“Follow your passion” is ubiquitous advice for people who strive to pursue a successful and fulfilling career. However, the attitude to this tip is highly ambivalent. The speakers in the given videos express opposite points of view on the notion “passion” as a fundamental criterion to make a glittering career.

Larry Smith in the first video advocates for “passion” as an indispensable ingredient to achieve success and reach your full potential. In the speaker’s opinion, a passion ignites work and lays the groundwork for a creative solution to any problem. Yet, people are struggling to find their real passion, mixing it up with an interest, which is shallow and trivial. Smith also broaches the subject of excuses people invent not to follow their passion. One of the plausible excuses the speaker focuses on is human relationships which are taken as a shield not to take any actions towards the dream. People are trying to make allowances for themselves as they do not want to sacrifice human relationships on the altar of great accomplishment.

In contrast, Benjamin Todd in the second video refutes the suggestions that following your passion guarantees a successful and rewarding career. To back up his stance, he mentions the research showing that people who heed the advice “follow your passion” do not always excel at their jobs or even do not find them rewarding and satisfying. Todd also points out that people’s interests are bound to change throughout their lives, so “follow your passion” advice is superficial, misleading and populist. Hence, instead of “following your passion”, he recommends “following your contribution” which means “do what is valuable”. The only way to make a worthwhile career, in the speaker’s opinion, is to find a job where a person can make a difference and help to solve social pressing problems.

Undoubtedly, there is some truth in both views, but I am inclined to agree with Larry Smith that passion plays a crucial role in making a brilliant career. We cannot ignore the fact that passions are difficult to prioritize but succeeding in figuring out your true passion can contribute substantially to living life to the full and thriving in it. What is more, only zealous and truly passionate people who put their heart and soul into what they are doing can make a real difference or even change the world. The rest are lay people.

You see, with some sleight of hand, anything can be turned into exam preparation.


Image credit: Photo by Ian Schneider on Unsplash

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to tame your IELTS pie charts

My Fulbright application or a teachable moment on essay writing

C2 Proficiency. Writing Task 2. Review (of a film I haven’t seen).

Top 8 mistakes Russian learners of English actually make